Hann objects that the three years have passed
retrospective response
On: in three years the major part of our land will be convinced the Lord hath spoken by me
Source quotation · R. Hann · 1810
FIRST PROPHECY.
From page 128 of “The Strange Effects of Faith:”—“It is said to me, the Lord will begin his strange work with a new century, and go on in such a manner to fulfil my prophecies, that in three years the major part of our land will be convinced the Lord hath spoken by me.”
This prophecy deserves a little to be animadverted upon:
In the first place, it is evident it has entirely failed; as the time specified for its fulfilment elapsed several years since, and not the least appearance of its being fulfilled yet. This then must have brought Joanna into confusion, and put her to her shifts. You will see this, by looking at the note attached to the prophecy in the second edition of The Strange Effects of Faith, where you will find that the Spirit which inspired and dictated this prophecy, was Joanna’s own judgment.
When I read this prophecy in the first edition, I very much stumbled at it, (for in that edition there is no such marginal note: but the prophecy is recorded as dictated by the Spirit like all the rest); for it being manifest that the prophecy had failed, I was sure it was not dictated by the Spirit of God. But when I found by the marginal note in the second edition, that Joanna confessed it came from her own judgment, I was very angry, being three parts convinced of her imposture, which I before suspected, for other reasons. This spurred me on to investigate, and to oppose: I sent to Joanna for information concerning the prophecy, and she sent me the same answer as is found in the note, (viz.) that it was her own judgment. Here the reader will take particular notice of the first words in the prophecy,—“IT IS SAID TO ME,” (viz.) by the Spirit: which words constitute it a divine prophecy, as much as any one prophecy in all the writings. It evidently appears then, that Joanna’s spirit of prophecy is no other than her own judgment; and this is exactly the same as our common fortune-tellers, that prophecy and tell fortunes from no other principle; which no one hesitates to call lies and deception, and which is sometimes punished according to its demerit.
The Prophecies of Joanna Southcott · R. Hann, The Prophecies of Joanna Southcott, eighth edition (1810), printed pp.3–4: FIRST PROPHECY and the complete two-paragraph objection, ending its demerit. Both pages visually collated; long s rendered s, running quotation marks removed, line-end hyphenation joined, whitespace normalized, emphasis plain.
Source reuse and transcription
Original 1810 English text, public domain; scan-host apparatus excluded.
Community response to this revision: 0
Published revision history
2026-09-21T02:03:32+00:00
FIRST PROPHECY.
From page 128 of “The Strange Effects of Faith:”—“It is said to me, the Lord will begin his strange work with a new century, and go on in such a manner to fulfil my prophecies, that in three years the major part of our land will be convinced the Lord hath spoken by me.”
This prophecy deserves a little to be animadverted upon:
In the first place, it is evident it has entirely failed; as the time specified for its fulfilment elapsed several years since, and not the least appearance of its being fulfilled yet. This then must have brought Joanna into confusion, and put her to her shifts. You will see this, by looking at the note attached to the prophecy in the second edition of The Strange Effects of Faith, where you will find that the Spirit which inspired and dictated this prophecy, was Joanna’s own judgment.
When I read this prophecy in the first edition, I very much stumbled at it, (for in that edition there is no such marginal note: but the prophecy is recorded as dictated by the Spirit like all the rest); for it being manifest that the prophecy had failed, I was sure it was not dictated by the Spirit of God. But when I found by the marginal note in the second edition, that Joanna confessed it came from her own judgment, I was very angry, being three parts convinced of her imposture, which I before suspected, for other reasons. This spurred me on to investigate, and to oppose: I sent to Joanna for information concerning the prophecy, and she sent me the same answer as is found in the note, (viz.) that it was her own judgment. Here the reader will take particular notice of the first words in the prophecy,—“IT IS SAID TO ME,” (viz.) by the Spirit: which words constitute it a divine prophecy, as much as any one prophecy in all the writings. It evidently appears then, that Joanna’s spirit of prophecy is no other than her own judgment; and this is exactly the same as our common fortune-tellers, that prophecy and tell fortunes from no other principle; which no one hesitates to call lies and deception, and which is sometimes punished according to its demerit.